There are legends, Ryan Coogler's new movie Sinners tells us, of people with the gift of making music so true it conjures spirits from the past and future. This is demonstrated at the film's halfway point when Sammi (Miles Caton) finally plays for a packed audience; As musicians and crowd lose themselves in the song, they're joined by ghostly revellers both long gone and yet to be born, forebears and descendants: A guitar-wielding rock-star, a DJ, a chinese Opera singer, breakdancers. And the music follows suit, morphing the instrumentation running beneath Sammi's blues number fluidly in and out of several different styles
It's an almost didactic demonstration of the universality and transcendent power of music. It's ridiculous in the best way possible, a huge gamble that pays off in a big way. The scene is the clear heart of the movie; It both neatly divides and bridges the film's period drama-heavy setup from the blood-soaked vampire horror that still lurks in the wings. It is, over everything else, a thing of beauty, and it firmly establishes Sinners as a bona fide musical.
But the film takes its time to get to that party, and to the monsters that gatecrash it. First we spend an hour following Smoke and Stack, twin brothers (both played by Michael B. Jordan in a characteristically great performance) who return to their small Mississippi town at the tail end of the prohibition from a years-long stint - first in the war, and then working for the Chicago mob.
They've come back to set up a juke joint (a mix between a casino, lounge and dance hall catering to a black clientele) at a sawmill they bought with ill-gotten gains. And because they fear the gangsters following them, they need get it done quickly; They arrive at morning, buy the place, and aim to have the grand opening that same night.
The brothers are bad news, but charismatic and profligate with their money, so soon an ensemble cast of colourful characters accretes around them. Sammi is their cousin and first hire: a gifted young bluesman and preacher's son who's blinded by the twin's glamour. Then Anne (Wunmi Mosaku), Smoke's estranged wife as a cook, Cornbread (Omar Miller) as a door man, Delta Slim (Delroy Lindo) and Perline (Jayme Lawson) as musicians, and many others.
Watching them go about their business, promoting their club and working acquaintances to put together their business is detailed, interesting and entertaining to the point that it's almost disappointing when it finally transitions to horror. The upshot is that all that hard work pays off by making the pain and misery inflicted on these people really hurt.
The vampires are led by Remmick (Jack O'Connell), an Irish child of the night who, like Sammi, has a musical streak. In fact, it's Sammi's performance that draws him to the juke joint just as things are getting into swing: Anne's narration at the beginning warned us that powerful music like that can draw evil spirits along with the bad; A neat nod to all the legendry linking the blues to the devil.
And that's the second half of the film: The vampires quickly multiply and lay siege to the sawmill, and a handful of survivors try to make it to morning. The film's vampire lore is surprisingly traditional (but I do love that at first the survivors think that they're haints) - the only wrinkle is that they share a sort of hive mind, another really cool touch which becomes very thematic.
While the vampires start out all white (and Remmick's first recruits are alluded to belong to the Klan), Coogler's script has a much more interesting tack on the type of menace they pose. Remmick comes as a fellow traveller, another oppressed soul looking for fellowship and true emancipation; An interesting nod to the way history has treated Irish peasantry. And the film backs his sincerity by giving him two musical numbers: a lovely renditions of Wild Mountain Thyme and The Rocky Road to Dublin as a lively jig. His lust for Sammi's blood is as much a need to share his gift with his flock as something more demonic.
All of this, while still keeping it crystal clear that he's a fucking monster.
As nasty as things get, this fellow traveller theme runs strong through the film and dovetails nicely along with an amazing, eclectic soundtrack by Ludwig Göransson (which veers from jangly americana to heavy doom-laden riffs) and the beautiful, diverse collection of songs.
And things do get nasty; People get killed in all sorts of ways and blood flows freely, all done through glorious practical and makeup effects. There's a surprising amount of action, all very well rendered - things are not crystal-clear all of the time, but it's a horror film, so that's fine. A bonus cathartic shootout at the end is a strong argument as to that the dismally poor action and shoddy structure of Black Panther was more down to Disney than any lack on Coogler's part.
And man, does he get to show off in this movie, both behind the camera and behind the pen, in ways both obvious (an early tracking shot following first a girl, then her mom as they simply cross a street particularly stands out) and more subtle (The way a half-picked cotton field underlines the hard work of the men and women out on the field, and how it would factor in making Smoke's shady offer all the more appealing).
The sets and wardrobe are on-point; Horror is notorious for working on tight budgets, but man if it isn't nice to see the a genre exercise to look as lavish as this. The cinematography (by
Autumn Durald Arkapaw) is similarly gorgeous, sporting a desaturated look that makes even blue skies look overcast. There a couple of overtly-murky, dark-set scenes, but nothing serious - that's about the only thing I can complain about the film's aesthetics. Elsewhere, I can grumble about missing out on quite a bit of dialog thanks to the thick accents, but that's obviously on me. A more serious complaint would be that the film is somewhat messy, sports some cheesy symbolism, and it's more than a little bloated and self-indulgent - but I don't begrudge it for any of that, not even it goes through more endings than Lord of the Rings. Even when it's corny, that sentimentality is hard-earned.
To be honest, the biggest problem I have with the whole thing is a trailer that gives entirely too much away, including the identity of several characters who become vampires. As ever: fuck marketing.
Sinners is a bold mix of elements confidently tied together into a coherent whole by top-notch filmmaking and storytelling. The rare movie where almost everything just works and feels natural; And that is a fine thing to be able to say about, of all things, a sensual vampire period drama musical.